Should Australia Introduce a Medical Specialty Match System?
- as per harry
- Mar 13
- 3 min read
Australia’s medical training system is unique. Unlike countries like the U.S., where medical graduates are matched into specialty training programs before they even start working as doctors, Australia takes a more “choose your own adventure” approach. Once you finish medical school, you start working as a junior doctor—and then it’s up to you to figure out your path.
This creates a lot of uncertainty. You could spend years working, sitting exams, and building experience, only to find yourself unable to secure a spot in the specialty you’ve been aiming for. So, is there a better way?
How Specialisation Works in Australia
In Australia, once you finish medical school, there’s no automatic entry into a specialty training program. The basic steps look like this:
Intern (PGY1/2) – Your “L-plates” year as a doctor. You rotate through different specialties under supervision.
Residency (PGY2+) – You gain more experience, get your full medical registration, and start planning your career path.
Registrar (PGY2+) - Time to level up. you have gaiend some experience in a particular area of medicine and now you are doing the job of a senior doctor but you are not on the training program for that specialty yet. AKA unaccredited registrar
Applying for Specialty Training – Depending on the specialty, you might need to complete specific rotations, pass exams, or gain research experience before you’re even eligible to apply.
Specialty Training – If you get accepted, you start training in your chosen field. If not? Well… you try again next year. Once you are on board you can now work as an accredited registrar.
For competitive specialties like surgery or cardiology, some doctors spend years—sometimes a decade—trying to get in. If they don’t, they either pivot to another specialty or stay in limbo, working as an unaccredited registrar. At some point you may wonder is it worth continuing to try to get into this specialty or should I change tracks and go down a different route entirely...
The U.S. Match System vs. Australia’s System
In the U.S., medical students sit their licensing exams and then apply for the National Resident Matching Program (NRMP). They rank their preferred specialties, hospitals rank their preferred candidates, and an algorithm pairs them up. By the time they graduate, they already know where they’re going and what specialty they’ll be training in.
In Australia, there’s no such centralised match. Instead, doctors apply to individual training programs—each with different criteria, timelines, and selection processes. There’s no guarantee of acceptance, and some specialties limit the number of attempts you can make before you’re locked out forever.
The Case for an Australian Match System
Would a match system work in Australia? Maybe—but with some key modifications.
A potential solution I thought about was a PGY3 or PGY4 Match, where doctors have at least a few years of real-world experience before selecting a specialty. This would in theory:
Reduce uncertainty – Doctors wouldn’t spend years chasing specialties they might never get into.
Encourage informed choices – After working in different fields, doctors would have a clearer idea of what they enjoy and excel at.
Improve workforce distribution – The match could include incentives for doctors to train in rural or undersupplied specialties.
The Downsides and Challenges
Of course, a match system isn’t perfect. Specialties have different training needs, and a one-size-fits-all approach could be difficult to implement. There’s also the risk of forcing doctors into specialties they’re not truly passionate about.
Still, something needs to change. The current system leaves too many doctors in career limbo, working endless unaccredited years with no certainty about their future.
After three years working as a doctor, I would say that most junior doctors have a pretty good idea of what specialty they want by the end of PGY2. A structured match system at this stage could make training fairer, more efficient, and less stressful.
What do you think? Should Australia introduce a specialty match? Let me know your thoughts :)
Watch the whole conversation here:
Listen to it instead https://tr.ee/-Q0CF0Yh1N
Comments